1. While this is a novel about one young woman’s determination to be an advocate for civil rights and to uplift the black community amid the challenges of early twentieth-century America, we also take note of the bustling presence of many people around her. Ivoe is loved and supported by her mother, Lemon; her father, Ennis; her siblings, Irabelle and Timbo; and others, such as Susan Stark, Miss Stokes, her young lover Berdis, and her typesetting and journalism teacher, Ona Durden. Which of these secondary characters is most memorable to you? Why?
2. Miss Stokes, the teacher who works hard to continue educating the children of Little Tunis after the school burns down, is one of four women who supports Ivoe as she grows up in the town, the other three being the wealthy Susan Stark, who opens her library to the voracious young reader; sage May-Belle; and Ivoe’s hardworking and wise mother, Lemon. Discuss how these four women are different from one another and the ways in which you think they influenced Ivoe. Discuss also what it means for this book about a black community to be populated by strong women such as them.
3. Though the relationships among strong women are a joy in this story, another relationship that is a source of great love and joy is that between Lemon and Ennis. Across many trials and hardships, their marriage remains stable and passionate. Why do you think this relationship and their joy in each other is such an important part of the story, even though it is not the central love story? What does it contribute to our idea of a striving black family in that period? Does it assert or challenge stereotypes? How so?
4. A little bit of literary play: In two meaningful instances, a pear fruit makes an appearance. First, Ennis appears with one on a day when Lemon is contemplating aborting her pregnancy. Years later, Ennis spots a pear high up on a tree and sits to rest, when he meets the man who will lead him to agricultural work that, tragically, will also lead to his imprisonment. What do you think is the significance of the pear? How does the presence of this fruit help us to think about possibility and loss in this story? Does it have any relation to Lemon’s knack for gardening and her renowned preserves?
5. On that note, Lemon’s skills and perseverance in gardening are a delight to read throughout the novel. What do you think is the significance of gardening and harvesting in this story? What do Lemon’s skills—and her preserves—mean to the family, and what do they come to mean to us readers?
6. Turning to a darker episode in the story: After Ennis and Irabelle are harassed and humiliated by a sheriff, Ennis instructs his daughter, “Don’t you never tell nobody about what happened” (p. 79). Why do you think Ennis wants to keep that incident a secret? What is he trying to hide from the rest of the family? What does it tell us about Ennis and how he sees his role as a father?
7. On a similar note, after Irabelle is attacked by two boys, ostensibly for her clarinet, Lemon and Ivoe try to file a complaint at the sheriff’s office. The sheriff refuses to take the complaint seriously: He says, “Must be a mighty strong gal you got to be fighting off two boys. . . . What you feeding her?” and “For the trouble this gone bring on you, you be better off if you just get the girl another clarinet” (p. 141). What do you think this exchange shows about authority and justice in Little Tunis society? How does it amplify the horror of the initial attack on Irabelle? How do you think this experience changes everyone in the family, particularly Ennis? Finally, thinking of both this attack and the previous incidence of assault on Irabelle, both sparked by her clarinet, what do you think the clarinet comes to mean in this story?
8. Susan Stark is a rare white woman in Ivoe’s life who supports her education. After recounting to Ivoe her own life, marked by struggle and not easy by any means, she says, “If you really want to know the truth, Ivoe, ain’t nobody free. . . . In the matter of all that living I just told you about I didn’t have a say in a lot of things. . . . That’s what it means to be just a woman—no say. But an educated woman has a say and choice! Ivoe, you’ve got more education than every white woman I know” (p. 134). What do you think it meant to Ivoe to hear these words from a wealthy white woman? How do these thoughts complicate what we may have assumed about the privilege of white people in that town and at that time? What does it tell us about the role of education in the lives of women?
9. College is a time of great personal growth for Ivoe. She realizes, for one, that she is attracted to women. How do you think her identity as a lesbian shapes her life? While we do not read too much about this aspect of her life, do you think it influences her advocacy work? Does it lead her to think differently about freedom and empathy?
10. College is also, of course, a time of intellectual growth for Ivoe. At dinner with Ona Durden, Ona asks Ivoe, “What work are you doing for the race?” (p. 102). Discuss how this question resonates across Ivoe’s life. How does Ivoe see her responsibility to her community growing and changing? What kind of groundwork does this question lay for Ivoe’s career?
11. Ivoe’s first lover, Berdis, is a passionate and spirited young musician when we first meet her. But over the years, failed relationships and soured ambitions change her, so that when we see her again, decades later, she is consumed with bitterness and is envious of Ivoe and Ona’s relationship. She cannot stand to be around their happy companionship. How do you think the choices Ivoe and Berdis made about their careers and life partners affected how their life stories played out?
12. While they are still in a relationship, Berdis and Ivoe have an argument over boycotting streetcars. Ivoe insists that, given the segregation of colored passengers—they may only occupy the last two seats of each car—they ought to boycott streetcars altogether. Berdis says, “Colored people choose the wrong things to be proud about. We’re barred from the best music shops, pay the same entrance fee at theaters . . . to sit in the buzzard’s roost, muss ourselves entering and exiting establishments through back alleys . . . Why is a damn trolley seat so important?” (pp. 112-13). How do you think you would respond to Berdis?
13. After disappointments and injustices on the job market in Kansas City, Ivoe finally takes a position in a candy factory. Here, she is frequently compelled to have sex with the forewoman. Was it a strategic choice on her part? What does this tell us about the way women contributed to the oppression of other women?
14. Timbo is portrayed as a somewhat idle, unfocused man, inclined to gamble and be inadequately present for his family. Roena admits sadly to Lemon that perhaps she ought not to have married him. In Kansas City, however, he finds a purpose: “Hell if Timbo knew where the thought came from that he alone could get colored men organized, but it was the first time in his life he had his own thoughts on something important and he was excited to see where they might lead him” (p. 200-01). Why do you think the author chooses to portray Timbo in this way, letting him meander in his life before finding purpose? How do these authorial choices translate into your experience of reading him? What impression of him do you come away with, and how does it inform your imagination of what society was like for young black men?
15. In planning for her newspaper, Jam on the Vine, Ivoe conceives of a column called “Woman About Town,” in which she plans to write about customs and manners by which black people might improve their place in society: “Her first published statement would be a gentle reminder of etiquette—to say ‘thank you’ and ‘if you please’ when receiving service and to speak softly. They should refrain from loudness and public ridicule of each other because the loud and blatant were never trusted. They should take all care in matters of hygiene, which was to whites a signal of moral judgment. They should take care in wearing pleasant hair . . .” (p. 230). Later, Ivoe acknowledges that she is ashamed of having offered such advice, which encourages a community to change their ways of life to appear “worthy” to others. What do you think led her to offer that advice in the first place? And how do you think she realized that she was wrong? What changes in her thinking does this shift demonstrate?
16. Along those lines, how do you think Ivoe’s experience of the unrest in Omaha changes her views of how justice and injustice are sustained? How do you think this experience makes her grow as a journalist and a civil rights advocate?
17. It is difficult to read about Ivoe’s journalistic investigation of incarceration, and about Ennis’s imprisonment and subsequent return to his family, without thinking about our present-day debates around the role of prisons in undermining black families and communities and robbing such communities of opportunity and stability. What do you think is the role of this account of the prison system in the novel? What is the author trying to remind us?
18. After having completed this book, what continuities—in terms of gender- and race-oriented struggles—come to mind between early twentieth-century America and the present day? What was your experience of reading this book in light of recent race-related unrest across American cities?
19. While the book touches on broad themes—black life in the south, migration to the north, the injustices of both race and gender—Ivoe’s life refuses to be a tidy reflection of her times. How does Ivoe complicate our views of that history? What does a reading of her life add to the history we already know?
20. A striking aspect of this novel is the use of nonstandard English in the dialogue. Lemon says to Roena, for example, “You and Ivoe the most leavingest gals I done seen. What make y’all generation so restless?” (p. 163). How do you find the experience of reading such English, which is, after all, inflected by histories that are silenced in standardized language? What qualities does it bring to the story? How would the story be different if it was written entirely in standard English?
21. In Paris, Ivoe experiences political freedom for the first time. How does this experience shape her thoughts on American democracy? As the pages of the book come to a close, but Ivoe’s life of activism and advocacy carries on, how do you imagine that her days in France will shape her future efforts? If you were to write the next chapter of Ivoe’s life, what do you think she would be passionate about?
Suggestions For Further Reading:
Crusade for Justice by Ida B. Wells; The New Jim Crow by Michelle Alexander; Citizen by Claudia Rankine; The Help by Kathryn Stockett; The Bluest Eye by Toni Morrison; The Color Purple by Alice Walker